This is the most common question in cruise planning - and the answer depends entirely on how you cruise. Some travelers swear they'll never book an inside cabin again, while others consider balconies a waste of money. Let's break down when each option makes sense.
The Case for Inside Cabins
Inside cabins cost 30-50% less than balconies - savings of $500-2000 per cruise. That money buys specialty dining, spa treatments, or shore excursions. Modern inside cabins aren't cramped dungeons; they're comfortable sleeping spaces with the same beds, bathrooms, and amenities as pricier rooms. If you'll spend all day at the pool, in port, or exploring the ship, why pay for a room you only use for sleeping?
The Case for Balconies
Nothing beats morning coffee watching the ocean or arrival in port from your private outdoor space. Balconies extend your living area significantly. For cruises with scenic sailing (Alaska glaciers, Norwegian fjords, Caribbean islands), balconies provide front-row views from bed. Some travelers feel claustrophobic without natural light. The balcony experience transforms cruising from transportation to destination.
When to Book Inside
Choose inside cabins when: you're budget-focused and want money for experiences; you'll rarely be in the cabin during daytime; you're taking a short cruise (3-5 nights) where ship time is limited; you prefer darkness for sleeping (insides are truly dark); you're cruising primarily for ports and activities rather than the ship itself. First-timers unsure of cruising might start inside to test the waters.
When to Book Balcony
Splurge on balconies when: the itinerary features scenic sailing (Alaska, Norway, Mediterranean); you want room to spread out; it's a special occasion (honeymoon, anniversary, milestone birthday); you're traveling with someone who needs natural light; the cruise has multiple sea days; you value starting and ending each day in peaceful privacy. Long cruises (7+ nights) benefit more from balcony investment.
The Middle Ground: Ocean View
Ocean view cabins add a window (or porthole) without the balcony premium - typically $150-400 more than inside. Natural light helps with wake/sleep cycles. Views are limited (you're looking at the side of the ship), but you can see weather and daylight. This works well for those who want light but won't use a balcony. Note: some ocean views have obstructed views from lifeboats - check deck plans carefully.
Virtual Balconies and Alternatives
Royal Caribbean's inside cabins on newer ships feature 'virtual balconies' - large screens showing real-time ocean views with sounds. It's not the same as real fresh air, but it provides light and the sense of connection to the sea. Some cruisers love them; others find them gimmicky. They typically cost slightly more than standard insides but far less than real balconies.
Location Matters More Than Category
A well-located inside cabin beats a poorly-located balcony. Mid-ship cabins feel less motion than bow or stern. Lower decks have less motion than higher ones. Avoid cabins under the pool deck, nightclub, or buffet (noise). Avoid cabins near elevators (traffic). Check deck plans for potential issues. A quiet inside cabin mid-ship often delivers better sleep than a noisy balcony near the anchor.
The Honest Answer
If the price difference is significant and you're budget-conscious: book inside and spend the savings on experiences. If scenic cruising matters, you're celebrating something special, or you simply love waking up to the ocean: the balcony investment pays emotional dividends. Neither choice is wrong - they're different ways to cruise. The best cabin is one you can afford without stress.